Text from the interactive explanation
Consequences of overtones in Raman spectra for assigning nickel anode surface structures as NiO2 during alkaline electrolysis
Justus Leist, Annika Neufischer, Timo Jacob, Albert K. Engstfeld
Original paperNature Catalysis · 2026 · Leist, Neufischer, Jacob & Engstfeld
While a nickel electrode splits water, laser light reports how its surface atoms vibrate. Faint, broad bands in that Raman spectrum were long read as fleeting oxygen intermediates. This study shows they are overtones — harmonics of just two lattice vibrations — and that the working surface is nickel dioxide, NiO₂, not NiOOH.
H₂O (0.01 M KOH, 1.54 V): I₁ 479 · I₂ 560 cm⁻¹ — overtones at 2I₁ 959 · I₁+I₂ 1,039 · 2I₂ 1,120
3 quanta: region III = 3I₁, 2I₁+I₂, I₁+2I₂, 3I₂
Eg + A1g · both lattice notes at once; the trails trace their sum
01 · The physics of a harmonic
One photon, two quanta
A Raman photon normally hands exactly one vibrational quantum to the material. That is why a perfectly harmonic crystal shows only its fundamental lines — for this surface, I₁ and I₂.
In a harmonic well every rung of the energy ladder is equally spaced, and light may climb only one rung at a time (Δv = 1). Real bonds are anharmonic: the rungs crowd together higher up, and two- or three-rung jumps become weakly allowed. Those jumps are overtones near 2× and 3× a fundamental; mixing the two notes gives combination bands such as I₁ + I₂.
The DFT spectra in this study are computed in the harmonic approximation, so they cannot produce such bands — which is why no calculation showed region II. Resonance enhancement alone does not explain a full second-overtone band either. The authors suggest that defects and weak coupling between the layers of layered materials enhance overtones.
Harmonic: equal rungs, only Δv = 1 allowed → one line, no overtones.
02 · The case file
Who made region II?
The broad bands between 900 and 1,200 cm⁻¹ have been read as superoxide reaction intermediates (Ni–OO⁻). Run the paper’s four tests on the measured spectra and see which suspect still fits.
A fleeting superoxide (Ni–OO⁻)
An O–O species formed on the surface during oxygen evolution.
O–H bending in NiOOH
Hydrogen in the lattice; NiOOH models put O–H bends at 900–1,200 cm⁻¹.
Overtones of NiO₂’s two lattice notes
Sums n·I₁ + m·I₂ of the two strong peaks at 479 and 560 cm⁻¹.
Pick a test. Each one replots measured spectra from the paper’s open dataset.
How to read the evidence
Each test swaps something and asks what every suspect predicts. A heavier atom slows any vibration it takes part in, so its band moves to lower wavenumber. A band that does not move contains no atom that was swapped.
Region I is shown at true scale; from 700 cm⁻¹ the intensity is magnified ×10, as in the paper.
03 · Calculated spectra
Which structure sings this song?
The team calculated Raman spectra with density functional theory for NiOOH and for NiO₂, as bulk crystals and as surfaces, each with two common corrections (PBE+D3 and PBE+U). Compare each with the measured spectrum.
Ni silver, O red, H white. Drag to turn the cell; ← → keys also rotate it when it has focus. Shown: relaxed bulk cells from the dataset, repeated 3 × 3 in-plane.
A second witness: the Ni–Ni ruler
X-ray absorption (EXAFS) and diffraction measure how far apart neighbouring Ni atoms sit. Many studies reported these distances for “NiOOH”. The bars are the ranges calculated here for each structure; drop in the reported values.
Calculated: NiO₂ 2.77–2.82 Å · NiOOH 2.87–2.99 Å · Ni(OH)₂ 3.12–3.23 Å.
04 · Potential and field
Turn the dial: new species, or a tuned field?
Raise the electrode potential and the spectrum changes. First Ni(OH)₂ turns into NiO₂. At still higher potentials the NiO₂ bands shift and reshape — changes the authors rationalize as a vibrational Stark effect: the interfacial electric field tunes the same vibrations, rather than new species appearing.
Peak O: Ni(OH)₂ oxidation (max ≈ 1.49 V). R: reduction on the way back. The current rising beyond ≈1.55 V is oxygen evolution.
Field lines brighten with potential and with ion concentration. Keeping the ion concentration fixed while changing pH leaves the field — and the spectrum — unchanged.
05 · Beyond nickel
Layered materials ring louder
Do overtones depend on how a material is built? The team measured cobalt and manganese oxides at two potentials each: a rigid, non-layered phase and a layered one.
The authors stress that this is a tendency, not a rule: layered materials are prone to defects and mismatches because their layers interact weakly, and they suggest this enhances or even induces overtones. Overtones also appear in some non-layered materials, and further studies are needed.
06 · What changes
If the surface is NiO₂, the oxygen story changes
The authors discuss what their assignment implies for how oxygen is made on nickel — implications, not new measurements.
NiOOH surface (the accepted view)
Deprotonate a lattice O–H group
Adsorb H₂O or OH⁻ at the freed site
Deprotonate, form O–O, release O₂
NiO₂ surface (this study’s assignment)
Deprotonate a lattice O–H group
Adsorb H₂O or OH⁻ directly
Deprotonate, form O–O, release O₂
AEM · adsorbate evolution All O₂ comes from the electrolyte. Two adsorbed O atoms recombining would be eased by NiO₂’s shorter O–O spacing (2.77–2.82 Å vs 2.87–2.99 Å in NiOOH), though it remains relatively large.
LOM · lattice oxygen A lattice O leaves with the O₂; the vacancy is refilled from OH⁻ or H₂O. Earlier ¹⁸O-labelling experiments showed lattice oxygen can take part.
What SERS can and cannot see
From how the spectra grew while the nickel film was oxidized, the authors estimate the probing depth at less than 3.2 nm — fewer than seven monolayers, possibly only the outermost layer. That is where NiO₂ is assigned. Below it, the bulk could be NiOOH or a mix of NiO₂ and Ni(OH)₂; SERS cannot resolve it.
Source & credits
Justus Leist, Annika Neufischer, Timo Jacob & Albert K. Engstfeld. “Consequences of overtones in Raman spectra for assigning nickel anode surface structures as NiO₂ during alkaline electrolysis.” Nature Catalysis 9, 1108–1120 (2026).
Article: doi.org/10.1038/s41929-026-01613-9 · nature.com article page · licensed CC BY 4.0. Data: Leist, Neufischer, Jacob & Engstfeld, open dataset on Zenodo, doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21899094 (CC BY 4.0).
Modifications: Spectra re-plotted from the authors’ open dataset, processed as in their notebooks (Savitzky–Golay smoothing, asymmetric-least-squares baseline), scaled to the first peak and resampled to 2 cm⁻¹; the overtone fit was re-run with the authors’ model. Lattice motions use the dataset’s DFT eigenvectors. Calculated spectra are drawn from the dataset’s DFT mode lists as sums of Lorentzians (γ = 18 cm⁻¹). Ni–Ni distances are from Table 2 of the article. Schematic graphics are illustrations. The extra ×30 magnification of region III in the opening graphic is our choice for legibility.
Topics in this iPaper
Chemistry
Ni-based anodes are among the most active and cost-effective oxygen evolution reaction catalysts for alkaline electrolysis.
Abstract, page 1108
Physics
Within the harmonic approximation, the positions of overtones correspond to integer multiples of fundamental modes, while combination modes result from the sum of different fundamental modes.
Results, 'Overtone and combination band dormation in Raman spectra', page 1113
surface enhanced raman spectroscopy
combining isotope-labelled in situ surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy measurements with density functional theory-calculated Raman spectra
Abstract, page 1108
density functional theory
we computed SER spectra for various bulk and surface structures using periodic DFT calculations with the Vienna ab initio Simulation Package
Results, 'DFT-guided assignment of Raman spectra', page 1111
oxygen evolution reaction
the implications for the mechanistic interpretation of the oxygen evolution reaction on Ni-based anodes are discussed
Abstract, page 1108
isotope labelling
The possible presence of hydrogen atoms in the NiOOH structure is elucidated through measurements using isotope-labelled water.
Results, 'Potential and electrolyte-dependent SER spectra', page 1110
vibrational stark effect
the observed shifts at varying pH, potentials and electrolyte composition are rationalized by a vibrational Stark effect
Abstract, page 1108
alkaline water electrolysis
Ni-based anodes are among the most active and cost-effective oxygen evolution reaction catalysts for alkaline electrolysis.
Abstract, page 1108